Negative Reputation

  • Fusionftw
    31st Mar 2020 Member 5 Permalink

    Are you sick and tired of seeing low effort posts (e.g. FREE ROBUX IF YOU UPVOTE MY SAVES), bad suggestions (e.g. HoW aBoUt AdDiNg WEED tHaT StIcKmEn CaN sMoKe?), unhelpful answers (e.g. having an issue that isn't fixed by a certain way, and someone posts that exact same way), and posts that are generally bad but don't break the rules?

     

    Well, here's the solution: Negative Reputation!

     

    A red button with a minus symbol would be placed right next to the +1 reputation button. Clicking it subtracts 1 from that post's reputation. Negative reputation would also be counted in the total reputation number on a user's profile.

     

    Posts with <0 reputation may be hidden with the message: "This post has an extremely low reputation. Show?".

     

    Potential Issues:

    • You may ask, "Well, Fusionftw, what if someone decides to bot negative reputation?".
      • A potential fix would be to allow moderators to reset reputation to 0, and/or even see the IP of whoever gives negative reputation (same as disliking a save).
      • Bans may also be issued for any one user to be mass disliking.
    • You may also ask, "Well, Fusionftw, I HAVE -999999999999999999999999999999999 REPUTATION, AND IT'S ALL THANKS TO YOU."
      • Making bad fourm posts isn't my fault. Besides, moderators would be able to reset reputation to 0.
      • Obligatory LOL when negative reputation is added and this post gets 9 million negative reputation.
    • You may also ask, "Well, Fusionftw, what if people decide to mass dislike old posts? Wouldn't that be considered necroposting?"
      • Well, yes. Giving posts older than 1 year negative reputation could be disabled.
    • You may also ask, "Well, Fusionftw, wouldn't the TPT fourms become Reddit now with the upvotes and the downvotes?"
      • That's not the intended result, and I feel like that's the reason why this suggestion is going to be rejected.
    Edited 8 times by Fusionftw. Last: 31st Mar 2020
  • INFINITY-BOI
    31st Mar 2020 Banned 0 Permalink
    This post is hidden because the user is banned
  • Cracker1000
    31st Mar 2020 Member 4 Permalink

    @Fusionftw (View Post)

     A few years back, there was actually a negative repo button. Users could use it if they didn't like the idea of a post etc.

    It was removed sometime later for reasons i don't remember.

     

    Adding it again doesn't sound like a nice idea, users would misue the button as we see with saves imao.

  • Fusionftw
    31st Mar 2020 Member 0 Permalink

    Oh, I didn't realize that it was added and removed already.

     

    Would limiting dislikes per player per day work?

    So that a player could give out 3 negative reputation per 24 hours, and once they've given 3, the button is greyed-out.

    Edited 2 times by Fusionftw. Last: 31st Mar 2020
  • 22Sambu
    23rd May 2020 Member 0 Permalink

    Same. I got my game Destroyable city DTTV ver and all of my games are disliked too much......
    22Sambu (your roblox player) Has been disliked a lot!
    necroposting is not my fault. or is it?
    think again. 
    [UP HERE ON THAT CHAT,MODERATORS! USERS!]
    I had been heavily disliked and then..... got no idea why.
    Why is the bots disliking my game? Is my Reputation failed to follow the hype or is it?
    AND NOT MY REPUTATION! THIS HAS MADE ME TOO BAD TO SEE THAT DISLIKES ARE A LOT OF TIMES!
    HERE IS THE LIST OF BEING DISLIKED ON MY PROJECTS.
    1. It's Too Crappy
       
    Some of my creations are crappy but some of them are beautiful because, we don't take moderators too        seriously because they could reset the dislike to 0 
    2. Too Bright for (some user's eyes)
       My Projects include:
    -Layzer (originally it said lay-zer)
    -PROT TV (or Proton Tube Television)
    and....
    -The Electric Shock.
    3. Dislike Bots.
    Aye.... I said earlier because they could have a lot of accounts that bots would do if i mind having it.
    they do by clicking the ? Button (also called a dislike button) a lot by repeating every projects.

    per year, to be exact.

    Moderators, I need your help to help me stop dislike bots and fix my reputation, Please ;-;......

    Edited 2 times by 22Sambu. Last: 23rd May 2020
  • INFINITY-BOI
    23rd May 2020 Banned 0 Permalink
    This post is hidden because the user is banned
  • 22Sambu
    24th May 2020 Member 0 Permalink

    INFINITY-BOI:

     

    dislike bots huh?

    that is hard , every bot should have different email and accept TPT message

    i dont think that's possible

    Yes. why don't this still dont happen tho?

     

     

  • INFINITY-BOI
    24th May 2020 Banned 0 Permalink
    This post is hidden because the user is banned
  • Fusionftw
    24th May 2020 Member 0 Permalink

    @INFINITY-BOI (View Post)

    TPT has no save API (at least that I know of), so bots would have to be run on a copy of the program, and go to each save over and over. It would take several seconds for bots to dislike each save.

    __________

     

    Also, this thread has spiraled out of control. I originally posted asking if negative reputation could be added, some person said that it was already added and removed a few years ago, and that was that. Then someone posted about how their saves were being disliked, which had nothing to do with the suggestion.

     

    __________

    22Sambu:

    because, we don't take moderators too        seriously because they could reset the dislike to 0 

     

    Great way to get a ban.

     

     

    Edited 7 times by Fusionftw. Last: 24th May 2020
  • jacob1
    24th May 2020 Developer 3 Permalink
    @22Sambu (View Post)
    Please see Rule S2.5. Excessive formatting is against the rules. You have used far more than necessary to get your point across.

    People dislike saves for many reasons. We have no control over that. If someone doesn't think the save is good enough, they may doenvote it. Also, there is no such thing as a dislike bot. While it would be possible to create one if you are dedicated, all downvotes are made by human players.

    @Fusionftw (View Post)
    I had thought about imposing limits on normal downvotes. Anyway, negative reputation got spammed. People would doenvote every post in a thread. It was getting annoying so we disabled it.
    Edited 2 times by jacob1. Last: 24th May 2020
Locked by LBPHacker: necro