What types of art are functionless?

  • Oats
    30th Jan 2013 Member 0 Permalink

    Just wanting to clarify what makes an artwork functionless. My Block Cat save was removed today (and I have no quarrels) whilst a few others stayed up there which gets me questioning.

     

    - Are we alowed to place in our saves functional items that aren't of the main form of the save but are just there as a safeguard? (and spam them?)

     

    - Do fonts get removed from front page?

     

    - As long as an artwork is artistic because it uses what tpt provides (e.g. trippy photon patterns) will it stay on front page?

     

    - Are cities (without flashy lights) functionless art saves and to that extent if I make a city in the same style as my previous save (lcry and deco) without them will it get removed?

     

    ^^ last one for personal use

     

    Again I have no quarrels with my saves being removed. (they all shot up the fp faster then most other saves which is the problem and I agree that it is fair)

  • TPTROXRLYITSTRUE
    30th Jan 2013 Banned 1 Permalink
    This post is hidden because the user is banned
  • Catelite
    30th Jan 2013 Former Staff 0 Permalink

    Generally speaking, if you want something to -stay- on front page, it needs to be exceptionally pretty, do something that confounds and impresses people, or fulfills some useful function that is difficult to achieve (eg, blowing something up in a particular way.)

     

    It doesn't especially matter if it's art, for example, if it's -impressive- art. If it's not impressive art and it does something cool, then it would probably stay. If it does something cool and it happens to also be impressive art, then it's usually especially popular. :P

     

     

    - Are we alowed to place in our saves functional items that aren't of the main form of the save but are just there as a safeguard? (and spam them?)

     

    Safeguard? How do you guard anything in a save? If a part of a machine is broken and you need a part to keep it from breaking, that's not likely to make people take it off front page.

     

    - Do fonts get removed from front page?

     

    Depends on if the font is impressive. I don't use fonts myself, so if there is something better, I -would- remove it to make room. :P

     

    - As long as an artwork is artistic because it uses what tpt provides (e.g. trippy photon patterns) will it stay on front page?

     

    >If artwork is artistic

     

    I don't even know what this means! @_@ Anything that is impressive stays on front page. We're just biased against static art patterns that don't move.

     

    - Are cities (without flashy lights) functionless art saves and to that extent if I make a city in the same style as my previous save (lcry and deco) without them will it get removed?

     

    Destroyably cities are hit or miss, whether they stay on front page is up to people voting. So if it impresses people by flashing on and off, then it would stay.

  • boxmein
    30th Jan 2013 Former Staff 0 Permalink
    @Catelite (View Post)
    Catelite

    - Are we alowed to place in our saves functional items that aren't of the main form of the save but are just there as a safeguard? (and spam them?)

    Safeguard? How do you guard anything in a save? If a part of a machine is broken and you need a part to keep it from breaking, that's not likely to make people take it off front page.

    What he means is that "let's put some electronics widgets in a save so you can't tell me it's just plain art"
  • Catelite
    30th Jan 2013 Former Staff 0 Permalink

    What's an electronics widget? o_o

  • boxmein
    30th Jan 2013 Former Staff 0 Permalink
    @Catelite (View Post)
    Gah, I might've used the word in a bad context. What I meant was some small marginally useful electronic parts.
  • Potbelly
    30th Jan 2013 Banned 0 Permalink
    This post is hidden because the user is banned
  • Catelite
    30th Jan 2013 Former Staff 0 Permalink

    It's not art if it moves in multiple parts so much, is it? o_o It still doesn't really matter, it's something you nearly need to post examples for.

  • jenn4
    30th Jan 2013 Member 0 Permalink
    This seemed to be art.


    This as well, but this was allowed to be in FP without hours of complaining.

  • Catelite
    30th Jan 2013 Former Staff 0 Permalink

    The first one triggers a sort of "Oh noo solid diamond >_<" response. The second one seems to even be a material save before it's opened.