I don't like raisin cookies either. I choose to throw it away, and it is lost from the world.
The next user falls into the sun.
...and instantly teleport out as discussed in http://what-if.xkcd.com/115/.
I be really nice and let the next user get off free.
I thank you and give you a moo cookie as I leave.
The next user is going to get slapped by a sack of moldy potatoes.
I get food poisoning, but am fine in the long term.
The next user discovers they have a fatal, incurable disease.
(make an Ebola joke and I will kill you myself)
It's not Ebola, so there's a decent chance I survive.
The next user is targeted by a drop bear.
"fatal"
"incurable"
whatever
Dropbears don't actually exist, so nothing happens.
The next user is a normal human who is teleported into the core of a neutron star. The heat and pressure there is so extreme that you are instantly imploded into a blob of neutron matter.